Stop Building a Content Library and Start Building a Path for Success

Your members aren’t lazy. They’re lost. Learn how to build a membership experience that guides, orients, and actually gets people results.

Home » Experience Design » Stop Building a Content Library and Start Building a Path for Success

You ever build something you know is good—
Like actually valuable, well-designed, beautiful even—
And then… no one touches it?

No one opens the post.
No one consumes the content.
No one shows up for the thing you poured yourself into.

And suddenly, you’re spiraling:

“Is it me? Are people sick of this stuff? Should I launch a challenge? Change platforms? Maybe I just need a better engagement strategy…”

Here’s the truth:

If your members aren’t using what you built,
It’s probably because they don’t know what the hell they’re supposed to do with it.

Not because they’re lazy.
Not because your offer sucks.
Not because your content isn’t high-value.

Because they’re human.

And humans?
They operate on the most fundamental mechanism of:

“What’s in it for me—right now?”

They hesitate.
They get distracted.
They forget why they joined in the first place.
And unless your system is built to reorient them quickly and help them keep their eyes on the prize, they’re gone.

Most Memberships Leave People to Figure It Out Alone

We build brilliant content libraries, deep archives, gorgeous onboarding sequences…

But if it’s not tied directly to the outcome they came for—
If they don’t know how it fits into the path they’re supposed to be on—
It’s just more noise.

And content without context?
It builds overwhelm.

Which leads to disengagement.
Which leads to churn.
Which leads to questioning your entire business model.

Here’s What Actually Drives Engagement:

You don’t need new tricks.
You need a better system.

A system that:

  • Names the destination

  • Maps the journey

  • Shows people where they are

  • Makes it easy and obvious what to do next

That’s how you turn content into progress.
That’s how you make engagement the natural byproduct of design—not a never-ending battle.

Because when members understand where they are, what to do, and why it matters—they show up.
Not just for you. For themselves.

TL;DR?

If they’re not engaging, it’s not because they don’t care.
It’s because they’re confused.

And confusion is a solvable problem—if you’re willing to stop optimizing for content consumption and start designing for human behavior.


If you’ve built something worth engaging with—but your metrics don’t reflect it—this is exactly the kind of obstacles I help solve.

Let’s make sure what you built actually lands.

Starlight Mundy

Starlight Mundy is an innovation strategist and founder of Bottled Lightning. She helps organizations design communities and growth systems that actually work; driving engagement, retention, and transformation at scale.

More on this topic

The Spark Loop framework diagram showing three connected hexagons labeled Grow, Engage, and Retain, representing the community-led growth system by Bottled Lightning.

Not Sure where to start?

See Where Your Membership is Silently Capping its Own Growth

The Breakpoint Diagnostic shows you which part of your membership system is actually holding you back or whether you’re ready for a bigger strategic move.

In less than 5 minutes, you’ll:

  • Get a clear read on your memberships biggest breakpoint.
  • See how your membership is really doing across the key pillars.
  • Get tailored next steps you can act on immediately — including when a fix pack, an audit, or a deeper engagement makes sense.